Home 5 Insights 5 The succession trap: Why internal transitions fail more often than expected

The succession trap: Why internal transitions fail more often than expected

Join Mariner

Throughout your career as a wealth advisor, you’ve spent time fostering client relationships, refining your process and growing your practice. You may also have counseled business-owner clients on their succession planning strategies. Yet when it comes time to transition your own book of business, you face a different set of challenges.

For many advisors, the most natural choice is to transition clients to a junior advisor or business partner. After all, an internal transition can help ensure service continuity for clients, preserve your culture and reward loyal team members.

However, the reality is often more challenging than many advisors anticipate. In fact, internal transitions can be, in some cases, significantly more complex and emotionally charged, and may be less successful than some advisors anticipate.

The potential succession trap in internal transitions

Advisors who choose an internal successor may encounter a succession trap driven by a few common challenges.

  • Emotional connection: If you’re like many advisors, your client relationships span years, often generations. You’ve supported them through major milestones, setbacks and successes, which can make it difficult to step away. At the same time, junior advisors may feel pressure to meet expectations, and clients may find it difficult to transition to someone new.
  • Unprepared successor: Despite improvements in training and mentorship, approximately 72% of rookie advisors leave the industry.1 Even strong candidates may lack experience in business development, leadership, client management or operations needed to run a practice independently.
  • Client attrition: The trusted relationships you’ve built may be difficult to fully replicate, even by the most diligent successor. If your practice is heavily dependent on you, client retention may suffer after the transition.
  • Unexpected circumstances: Even well-planned transition plans can be disrupted by unexpected health issues, market shifts or other emergencies that force an advisor transition.
  • Funding challenges: Internal buyers often lack the capital to fund an upfront purchase at the desired valuation. This can lead to seller financing, earn-outs or phased equity transfers that may impact your post-transition plans. Without the right structure, your deal may undervalue your life’s work.

How to avoid the succession trap

You’ve spent your career helping clients plan for their financial futures. Now it’s time to do the same for yourself. The following strategies can help you plan a more effective transition.

  • Start early: Many successful transitions begin five to 10 years before an advisor’s anticipated departure date.
  • Deliberately develop your successors: Invest in training, mentorship, leadership development and gradual increases in responsibility. Provide exposure to both client work and practice management, including business development and operations.
  • Provide opportunities to foster client relationships: Involve your teammates in client meetings, reviews and ongoing communications. Give junior advisors opportunities to lead client interactions and reinforce their role with clients over time.
  • Carefully structure your deal: Work with valuation, legal and tax professionals to structure a sustainable deal. Consider options such as phased equity transfers or performance-based earn-outs.
  • Establish solid governance and legal structures: Successful transitions are supported by strong partnership, buy-sell and operating agreements. Use these structures to establish clear roles, decision-making protocols and contingency plans for unexpected situations.
  • Consider your goals for the next stage of your practice: What do you hope to accomplish with your transition? How can you ensure you find the right successor to carry out these wishes? At Mariner, we can help you find a natural succession path that allows you to get back to the heart of what you love to do. Overall, those who consider their objectives early in the exit planning process may be better prepared to achieve their goals.

Turning the succession trap into a successful transition

For many advisors, an internal succession can be a rewarding way to exit, preserving client relationships, rewarding team members and maintaining continuity. However, success depends on proactive, multi-year planning that addresses emotional, financial and operational challenges.

Firms that approach succession with this level of intention may be better positioned to navigate transitions more smoothly. At Mariner, that means supporting advisors with the structure, resources and guidance to plan ahead, develop successors and transition with confidence.

When done well, succession becomes more than an exit strategy. It becomes a way to help protect what you’ve built and position it for what comes next.

Sources:

¹ https://www.advisorhub.com/more-than-72-of-rookie-advisors-still-fail-out-of-the-industry-cerulli/

This article is provided for informational purposes only and reflects general observations about advisor development and firm culture. The observations expressed herein are based on Mariner’s perspective and approach to advisor development. Outcomes may vary, and no specific results are guaranteed.

Mariner is the marketing name for the financial services businesses of Mariner Wealth Advisors, LLC and its subsidiaries. Investment advisory services are provided through the brands Mariner Wealth, Mariner Independent, Mariner Institutional, Mariner Ultra, and Mariner Workplace, each of which is a business name of the registered investment advisory entities of Mariner. For additional information about each of the registered investment advisory entities of Mariner, including fees and services, please contact Mariner or refer to each entity’s Form ADV Part 2A, which is available on the Investment Adviser Public Disclosure website. Registration of an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

Latest Resources

Join the Mariner Momentum

At Mariner, behind every advisor is access to a team of advisors — whether you want to join our team as an advisor or maintain your independence. Fill out the form below and our advisor talent team will be in touch soon.